Updated Everlane Shoes Review: If this is your first purchase at Everlane, you can get free shipping with my invite link here.
If you have any questions, leave a comment below.
One of my favorite discoveries in the last couple of years is Everlane shoes. I appreciated that most of their shoes are made in Italy and that Everlane uses factories with a score of 90 or above on a compliance audit that checks for fair wages and working conditions. And there’s detailed information about each of the factories so that customers can learn more about how and where the products are made.
I wear Everlane shoes almost every single day! As a teacher, I walk and stand about 3-4 hours a day — my shoes have gotten a good comfort test every day at work for this Everlane shoes review!
Favorite Everlane shoes?
Shop the post — click on the photo for more information about each shoe that’s reviewed below:
How do Everlane shoes fit?
Most Everlane shoes run a tad small and narrow. I suggest checking their sizing recommendation for the style you order and perhaps ordering a half size up. Most of their shoes are made of leather in two basic types: stiff leather that needs some breaking in time, and their Day line of buttery soft leather that molds to your foot and requires little to no break in.
Most Everlane shoes don’t have a lot of support in the soles, but I’ve found that because they’re so well made, they’re very comfortable, even for long days of walking and standing. The soles of the Day Glove, for example, don’t have much arch support but the soles are soft and cushy, and they feel great on my feet.
Do Everlane shoes work for wide feet? I recently developed a bunion on one of my feet, so unfortunately, I know the answer to this question first-hand. I had to get rid of some of my Everlane shoes because the narrower fits no longer worked for my sensitive foot.
If you have wide feet, I think these shoes would work for you: any of the Reknit line because the fabric is stretchy, the Day Boots because the leather is soft, and the Rain boots.
Do Everlane shoes stretch?
Yes and no. All of their shoes that I’ve tried have stretched enough to accommodate my feet. Two especially stiff and narrow ones required the use of a shoe stretcher (so useful!). As mentioned above, the shoes made of stiff leather do need some break-in time, but they stretch after some wear. In contrast, shoes from the Day line are made of super soft leather and therefore stretch and mold to your feet and need much less break in time.
Honest Everlane Shoes Reviews
Table of Contents
Everlane Italian Leather Chelsea Boots (amazing!)
I love these boots so much! These boots show what I think Everlane does best…high quality, beautiful details, and timeless style.
Like Everlane’s best shoes from past seasons, the Leather Chelsea Boots are made at a carefully chosen factory in Italy. In fact, this one is tiny, located in Florence, Italy, with a history of making beautifully constructed shoes that last.
Here’s why I love them so much:
— The leather on these boots is so soft yet thick. It feels like it will mold to my feet with no pinching, yet is substantial enough to last a long time. This is in contrast to Everlane’s Day Boots, which are beautiful and also very comfortable but made from thinner leather that scuffs easily.
— These boots are VERY comfortable. This is huge for me because I have a bunion on one foot, which makes it hard to find shoes that feel great. Even though the toe comes slightly in, there’s no pinching or pushing. The ankle has padding that makes them feel great against my legs. The soles are supportive without feeling clunky; in fact, they have a cushioned insole for extra comfort.
— The dark red edge and light rubber soles add an element of surprise, while the toe is just rounded enough to have a timeless look (i.e. not too square or pointy). I love the look!
How do the Italian Leather Chelsea Boots fit?
True to size! I usually wear a 7.5 and that’s what I ordered. There’s plenty of room for me to wear thick socks in winter.
The verdict? YES! These might be my favorite Everlane shoes ever! Definitely worth the price on sale or not. Looking for something dressier? Check out the beautiful City Boot.
Shop for Everlane Italian Leather Chelsea Boots here.
Everlane Day Boots: another favorite!
These boots are gorgeous! The day boot is made of buttery soft leather, like their day glove flats, and a stacked heel that’s just the right height. These boots are comfortable enough that I can wear them to work for several hours. I even wore them in Rome for New Year’s Eve and walked several miles that night.
How do the Everlane day boots fit?
They’re true to size, so for me, the 7.5 fits perfectly. Fortunately, there was no break in time needed for these boots because the leather is so soft. Even though the toe box is slightly narrow, they don’t come to a point and there has been no pinching on the sides of my feet or toes. The only issue I’ve had is that the ball of my foot feels sore if I stand or walk in them for several hours, but in my opinion, this is expected.
The verdict: Yes! These are one of my favorites, especially because the leather is so soft and comfortable right out of the box. The perfect boots for a mix of comfort and classic style.
Shop for Everlane day boots
Everlane Day Glove: My Favorite Flats!
These are one of Everlane’s most popular items and for good reason. Not only are they very comfortable, but the style makes them super versatile, too. I love the red for a pop of color or snake skin that dresses up any basic outfit of jeans and a sweater.
These are my go-to shoes for both travel and work, and I’m really impressed with how they’ve held up. The only issue I’ve had is that after 1.5 years of wear, the leather on the very front of the shoe has started to scuff, but it blends in if I use a leather protectant. In short, these really are some of the best flats you can buy.
For my first pair, I chose the neutral mocha color, but I’d suggest the tan or caramel colors instead. I wear these shoes with jeans, cropped pants and skirts. There’s no need for a liner or low-cut sock inside because the shoes don’t rub on my feet and there are two small holes for ventilation. You can see how soft the leather is and how well they’ve held up after a year of wear in this photo:
How does the Everlane Day Glove fit?
They’re supposed to fit like a glove with buttery soft leather that conforms to your foot, and it’s true! They really are extremely comfortable.
These fit true to size. They felt snug across the top of my foot and in the toe box at first but quickly stretched out just enough. No blisters or discomfort, and that’s still true after more than a year of wear!
The verdict: Yes! The Day Glove is super comfortable and can be worn all day.
Shop for Everlane day glove flats
Everlane Glove Boots: so comfy!
These boots (in black) are a recent addition to my wardrobe because I needed new, more comfortable boots. I’d heard that the Reknit line of shoes from Everlane are more comfortable due to the stretchy fabric. I like these boots but I don’t love them. I know people rave about the look and fit, but I’m just not sold on the fabric yet.
The rest of the boot reminds me of their Day Boot, which I love. The sole has a little bit of cushion to help with hours of standing/walking, and the heel is a pretty brown stacked heel that’s just the right height. The fabric is made from recycled water bottles, making them a great choice for sustainability, but they’re not vegan since there’s a thin leather strip down the back.
How do Everlane Reknit Glove Boots fit?
These fit true to size, and do not run narrow. The stretchy fabric hugs your foot but can allow for extra room if you wear socks or have a bunion or just need them to give a little. Take your usual size.
Everlane claims that these are their most flattering boot because of the slim opening (“no ankle gap”), but this was almost too small on me! I have wider ankles, but just be aware of this if you do, too.
The verdict: Maybe. If you’re looking for a comfortable boot that’s not leather, this is a great choice.
Shop for Everlane Glove Boots
Everlane Court Sneakers: my favorite casual shoes
I love the look of these shoes, and they’re so comfortable. In fact, I liked them so much that they were my most-worn shoes last spring. Take your true size–these don’t run small at all.
Everlane Rain Boots
The Everlane rain boots are the most comfortable rain boots I’ve tried. A sturdy, cushioned sole makes a big difference — it’s not floppy like the typical rubber rain boots, and the traction means you can wear them on slick roads or even for hiking in wet weather. The sole is substantial enough to give your foot some distance from the ground, and the lining is insulated, so these boots feel warm even on an unusually cold day like today here in Northern California.
How do the Everlane rain boots fit?
They come in whole sizes, and Everlane suggests sizing down if you’re in between. I typically wear a 7.5 and ordered the 8 before seeing their tip to size down. With regular socks they feel a tad big, and because I usually don’t wear thick socks here in California, I am going to heed their advice and exchange them for the size 7. They fit more like Blundstones or similar boots that have pull tabs, so I need to maneuver my foot a bit to get them in, but once they’re inside, there’s plenty of room without them feeling clunky and oversized like other rain boots.
The verdict: Yes! These are cute and comfortable and super functional but run large so size down. I thought the all black was too harsh and wish I’d gotten them in the toffee color.
Shop for Everlane rain boots
Everlane Day Heel
I tried a couple of other pairs of heels before deciding on the Everlane day heel, and I’m so glad I did. I wasn’t sure I’d like the look of these, but they are so cute on. The heel is a perfect height for work or day-to-day wear.
Even though they haven’t stretched enough for a truly comfortable fit in the toe box, I’m tempted to get them in a lighter color for summer. I also have them in black for the perfect dressy work outfit.
How does the Everlane day heel fit?
The flexible back of the shoe is genius! Unlike on the Day Loafer, the soft elastic of the Day Heel doesn’t dig into my heel at all, and it allows the shoe to go on easily and fit with a bit more give than the average shoe. However, the front of the shoe is a bit tight on me and the leather is stiff, so I’d suggest going up a half size.
Check the sizing information on Everlane for this shoe — they used to have a “narrower fit” but recent releases have been more true to size.
How do I wear the Everlane day heel?
I wear these heels to work with slim ankle length pants. I wear them only with bare feet and never with tights because the heel slips off. But because they’re tight, I don’t wear them when I have to do much walking.
The verdict: For me, maybe. Many people love them, and I like the look but they just don’t work for my feet because the toe box is too tight for me. These are well made shoes that come in a fun variety of colors, so you’ll probably love them.
Shop for Everlane day heel here.
I think you might be developing your own little travel show niche! I appreciate these reviews as I hate to shop and I prefer people to narrow down the choices for me!
I like reviews from “real people” too. I actually search for blogger reviews of more expensive items before I buy them and always read the reviews on the clothing websites, too.
I love the Everlane cardigan you are wearing from the first picture! My first shoe purchase from them was the Modern Babo and I LOVE them. The leather is particularly soft and I like that you can wear the heal up or down for versatility.
You recommended the Modern Babo to me once, and you were actually one of the reasons I looked more closely at Everlane shoes!
I recently purchased my first pair of Everlane Loafers in black.
The most comfortable pair of shoes I have ever bought.
When you think of Everlane think of ultimate comfort.
Customèr service is outstanding.
That’s great to hear! And I agree that they have good customer service. It’s nice to deal with a company that is not so big–it feels more personalized, and they listen to feedback!
This is a great review, thank you!! I recently bought a pair of Everlane’s V Heel and I LOVE them but would love a pair not in suede, too. Your thoughts were super helpful to read in thinking about fit and styling!
So glad you found it helpful! Buying shoes online isn’t easy, but Everlane’s shoes are worth the extra time it takes to figure out the right size. 🙂
I have never heard of the Everlane brand before. I really loved the look of the shoes. I cannot wait to try my first pair. Thanks!
I am so glad i’ve discovered Everlane products. I find it hard to get shoes of a narrower fitting and what I have recently purchased are a delight. Have now received my second pair of day glove style , the colours are as advertised and for me sizing is just right, I hope to purchase more as time goes on so am hoping this style and size will continue to be manufactured for the next few years as I am sure other customers will have a similar comment.
I agree–I’m always pleased with their products. They’re definitely good for narrower feet. Mine are normal width, maybe a tad wide, and some of their styles work better for me than others (i.e. the ones that don’t have pointy toes, unless I size up).